As everyone knows, I normally don’t blog more than once a week but there are exceptions. I had a bit of time this morning and this is a very short blog entry, so I decided to do a blog entry more than once this week. I am not at all sure about my schedule for
The Case for Why McDonnell Douglas as a Summary Judgment Tool Makes No Sense
By William Goren on
This week’s blog entry discusses Justice Thomas with Justice Gorsuch joining concurring opinion in Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, here. By now, you most likely know that the opinion for the Court written by Justice Jackson, holds that a higher standard of proof is not in order if you are from a…
Osseo Area Schools Decided
By William Goren on
Posted in 504, ADA, Constitutional law, Federal Cases, IDEA, Rehabilitation Act, Title I, Title II, Title VI of Civil Rights Act
Within the last week, the Supreme Court has come down with two decisions of relevance to our blog (Osseo Area Schools and Ames). Each is worth a separate blog. This week’s blog entry is going to be the Osseo Area Schools, which I previously blogged on its oral argument here. As usual, the blog…
A Two for One: Huber en banc and Magic Mushrooms
By William Goren on
Before getting started on the blog entry of the week, housekeeping matters. Next week I will be traveling most of the week, so do not expect a blog entry from me next workweek. Also, I just did an hour long interview with Claudine Wilkins, Esq., where we had a fantastic discussion about the federal and…
Employers and PHP’s are Subject to Disability Discrimination Laws
By William Goren on
I hope everyone had a great Memorial Day weekend.
As I have mentioned previously, the last few years have found me increasingly involved in the area of working with counsel representing healthcare professionals who are being forced out of the profession because of their disability. Part of that process includes people being put into…
Unreasonable Delay is Actionable, Adverse Action Unnecessary, and More Good Stuff
By William Goren on
Before getting started on the blog of the week, a housekeeping matter. I usually get my blogs up on Monday and sometimes Tuesday or even Wednesday. However, my daughter just finished her third year of college and is home for a short time before starting her summer gig. So, my schedule for the next couple…
Justice Souter’s Impact on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
By William Goren on
As many of my readers know, Justice Souter died last week. I thought I would explore his legacy with respect to the rights of persons with disabilities. As usual, the blog entry is divided into categories and they are: opinions for the court; concurring opinions; dissenting opinions; and Heller v. Doe, a dissenting opinion the…
Confluence of State and Federal Laws When it Comes to Service Animals
By William Goren on
Today’s blog entry is an update on a prior blog entry we discussed here. In the prior blog entry, we discussed how the police could escape liability when a place of public accommodation did not do the right thing with respect to allowing a service dog in its premises and the police were called.…
Osseo Area School District Supreme Court Oral Argument
By William Goren on
Yesterday, the United States Supreme Court heard oral argument in the Osseo Area School District case, transcript here. It was ostensibly about whether a higher standard for damages existed for IDEA claim than for the ADA/Rehabilitation Act claims. It turned out to be something different altogether after both sides agreed that the standard should…
§309 Contains a Fundamental Alteration Defense
By William Goren on
I hope everyone had a happy Passover and a happy Easter. For those who are Roman Catholic, my condolences on the passing of the Pope.
Today’s blog entry concerns §309 of the ADA. It asks the question of whether fundamental alteration applies in §309 cases. The case of the day is Albert v. Association…